Experiments in Surgery & Medicine on the Western Front (Edexcel GCSE History)
Revision Note
Author
Joel DavisExpertise
History
Advances in Surgery During WWI - Summary
The type and extent of injuries on the Western Front led to the use of many new techniques to treat wounds and infections. The number of casualties allowed doctors and surgeons to perfect their methods. Based on Lister's work on antispetics, the Carrel-Dakin method, revolutionised the treatment of infection on the Western Front. The Thomas Splint and x-rays existed before the First World War. The environment of the Western Front demonstrated their effectiveness. Casualties in key battles such as Cambrai benefitted from the developments in blood transfusions, which underwent significant progress from 1915-1916. Many key individuals were pivotal in the evolution of blood transfusions. There were also new techniques devised in brain surgery and plastic surgery. The contribution to medicine and surgery led to the successful treatment of new types of injuries and meant men could return to society after the war. |
New Techniques in Wound & Infection Treatment
The RAMC struggled to treat soldiers with infections such as gas gangrene:
Contaminated conditions on the Western Front made it difficult to perform aseptic surgery
Dressing stations and Casualty Clearing Stations (CCSs) were often overcrowded. This made aseptic surgery less achievable
There were several methods of treatment used to help those with infection:
Technique | Description |
Wound excision or debridement | Cutting away dead or infected tissue from around the wound This was done to stop the infection spreading The wound was then stitched back up |
Carrel-Dakin Method | Chemical antiseptics like carbolic lotion failed to treat gas gangrene By 1917, sterilised salt solutions were passed through the wound instead The solution only lasted for six hours. |
Amputation | If debridement or the Carrel-Dakin method failed, amputation was used By 1918, 240,000 men had lost limbs Removing the limb prevented the infection from spreading to the organs |
The Thomas Splint
Wounded soldiers with compound fractures often died from blood loss or infection during transportation:
Fractures to the femur were particularly serious
The splint used to keep their leg rigid was ineffective
Difficult terrain made it more likely that broken bones would damage the muscle
The infection spread before the soldier arrived at a CCS
The use of the Thomas Splint helped to reduce these problems
Placed on a soldier's leg they could then be safely carried on a stretcher
Kept the injured soldier’s leg rigid by pulling the bones and joints back together
Reduced the chance of internal bleeding
It became less necessary to use amputation
Timeline of the Thomas Splint
Worked Example
Describe two features of the use of the Thomas Splint.
4 marks
Answers:
It was used to stop the movement of a soldier’s fractured femur (1); excessive moving caused heavy bleeding (1)
It increased the chances of survival (1); from 1916 the survival rate increased from 20% to 80% (1)
This answer would receive full marks because it identifies two main features or characteristics of the Thomas Splint. Each feature is supported by a relevant piece of knowledge.
Exam Tip
Don’t confuse the Thomas Splint with a tourniquet:
The Thomas Splint was used on a soldier’s leg who was placed on a stretcher.
A tourniquet is used to prevent blood loss, and an injured soldier could move with it on.
Mobile X-Rays
X-rays enabled doctors to locate bullets and shrapnel before surgery
They did have some drawbacks and:
Could not detect objects like clothing fragments
Injured soldiers had to remain still during an X-ray
X-rays overheated quickly which made them less reliable
Three machines were used in rotation to solve this problem
Base Hospitals and some CCSs used unmoving X-rays:
Marie Curie had equipped 20 mobile x-rays for the French army
Close to the frontlines six mobile X-rays were used
The quality of the scans was not as good, but the ability to travel to injured soldiers across the Western Front was very convenient
An example of a mobile x-ray unit
The Battle of Cambrai & Blood Bank
Blood transfusions in the British sector
Blood transfusions were used from 1915 in Base Hospitals and 1917 in CCSs
Many key individuals contributed to the development of blood transfusions on the Western Front from 1915-16:
Key individual | Discovery |
Lawrence Bruce Robertson | Used a syringe to transfer blood from the donor to the patient. |
Geoffrey Keynes | Designed a portable blood transfusion kit for use at the frontlines: Stored blood could not be used as there was no refrigeration. Added a device to help prevent the blood from clotting. |
Richard Lewisohn | Added Sodium citrate to blood to prevent blood from clotting. |
Richard Weil | Discovered Sodium citrate allowed refrigeration of blood refrigerated and storage for two days. |
Francis Rous and James Turner | Added Citrate glucose which allowed storage of blood for up to four weeks. |
The blood bank at Cambrai
During the Battle of Cambrai in 1917, Doctor Oswald Hope Robertson stored 22 units of universal blood in glass bottles
The blood was:
Collected 26 days before being used
Stored in ammunition boxes packed with ice and sawdust
Of 20 Canadian soldiers treated for shock from blood-loss, 11 survived
It demonstrated the potential of blood transfusions to save lives
Worked Example
How could you follow up Source A to find out more about the use of blood transfusions on the Western Front?
In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.
4 marks
Source A: From an account written after the First World War by Charlie Shepherd. Charlie Shepherd was a soldier who fought in the war. Here he is describing his experiences in a hospital on the Western Front in 1915.
I was in the hospital. They wanted a volunteer to give blood for a transfusion. I volunteered and they checked that I was the same blood group as the soldier who needed blood. |
Answers:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up: ‘they wanted a volunteer to give blood for a transfusion’. (1)
Question I would ask: What would happen to the patient if a volunteer could not be found to give blood? (1)
What type of source I would look for: RAMC records from 1915 for hospitals carrying out blood transfusions. (1)
How this might help answer my question: The records would show how many injured soldiers died from blood loss or shock rather than from a fatal injury. (1)
This answer would receive full marks because it provides an appropriate question related to the detail selected from the source. The suggested source is precise and explains how it would answer the question.
Advances in Surgery
Head wounds accounted for 20% of all wounds in the British sector of the Western Front
Injuries were mainly the result of bullets and shrapnel
Why were injuries to the brain such an issue in World War One?
The illustration below shows why brain injuries were so dangerous
An illustration of how serious brain injuries were in World War One
How did the treatment of brain injuries improve?
A large number of brain injuries and facial injuries led to new medical developments:
Type of Surgery | Key Individual | Medical Development |
Brain Surgery | Harvey Cushing | An American neurosurgeon Used magnets to remove metal shrapnel from the brain. Local anaesthetic did not swell the brain during surgery like a general anaesthetic. Had an operation survival rate of 71% compared to the average of 50%. |
Plastic Surgery | Harold Gillies | A New Zealand doctor specialised in ENT Became interested in facial reconstruction during the war. Used skin grafts to help restore an injured soldier’s face. Helped develop a specialist hospital in Kent, called the Queen’s Hospital. By 1917, 12,000 surgeries had been carried out here. |
You've read 0 of your 0 free revision notes
Get unlimited access
to absolutely everything:
- Downloadable PDFs
- Unlimited Revision Notes
- Topic Questions
- Past Papers
- Model Answers
- Videos (Maths and Science)
Did this page help you?