Ashura (AQA GCSE Religious Studies A (8062))

Revision Note

Glenn Millington

Expertise

Religious Studies

Ashura - Origins & Meanings

Ashura

  • Ashura is a Muslim day of sorrow and is most significant in Shi’a Islam although it is important for all Muslims

    • Therefore, for Shi’a Muslims it is not seen as a festival that can be celebrated but more of a somber commemoration

  • The ten days leading up to Ashura are a period of mourning for Shi’a Muslims

  • Shi’a Muslims commemorate the death of Husayn (Grandson of Muhammad pbuh), Ali’s son, in battle in Karbala in Iraq

    • On one side of the battle were the forces of the Umayyad Caliphate, who were trying to rule the Muslim world. On the other side was a small band led by Husayn, a grandson of Muhammad (pbuh), and a rival claimant to the leadership of Islam

    • Muslims believe that Husayn’s camp was set on fire and their bodies were trampled upon by the horses of their enemy

    • Husayn and the male followers were killed

  • Although Ashura is important to both Shia and Sunni Muslims, it is viewed differently due to differences in beliefs

    • Sunni Muslims may mourn the loss of life within the Prophet’s family

    • However, it is observed differently by Shi’a Muslims, owing to the emphasis on the belief in the Imamate

    • This belief in the authority of the spiritual descendants of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) means that imams are leaders appointed by God to be Muhammad’s successors

    • Husayn was part of the imamate and therefore his death has greater significance for Shi’a Muslims

  • Ashura is a reminder of the suffering the Shi’a community has experienced, as they have been persecuted as a minority

    • Processions during this time are often used as protests against injustice

  • Shi’a and Sunni Muslims also refer to it as the day of atonement, when the Israelites were freed from slavery in Egypt

    • They remember the fast that Moses made in gratitude for God parting the red sea allowing the Israelites to escape from pharaoh

  • Others believe it is the day that Noah left the ark after the flood

 

Muslim practice during Ashura

  • On Ashura, Muslims wear black and plays are often performed to remind Muslims of the events that led to Husayn’s death

  • In some countries it is a public holiday

  • Shi’a take part in a public expression of grief and mourning

    • Re-enactments of the story take place

    • Reading of poems that retell the story

  • Some Shi’a Muslims flagellate to connect with Husayn’s death and suffering

    • In some circumstances men may beat themselves with chains or cut their heads with swords

    • Some religious leaders have condemned self harm and believe that it is wrong to harm the body God gave them

    • UK leaders encourage people to donate blood instead

  • Some will go on pilgrimage to the tomb of Husayn

  • Some believe that Muhammad (pbuh) nominated it to be a day of fasting

    • Originally this was a time when all Muslims fasted

    • When Muhammad (pbuh) said that Muslims should observe sawm during Ramadan, fasting on Ashura became voluntary

    • Many Sunni Muslims fast during this time but it is not compulsory

    • It is believed that fasting may absolve people of sins from the previous year

  • It is a day to show kindness to family and the poor

    • Mosques will often provide free food for people during the ten day mourning period

  • It is also a day to recite prayers and learn from Islamic scholars

Worked Example

Explain two contrasting ways in which Muslims celebrate Ashura

[4 marks]

Answer:

Shi’a Muslims might wear black clothes and re-enact the story of the death of Husayn to commemorate a member of the imamate

Some Muslims would take the opportunity to show kindness to others and mosques may provide free food to help the poor

Commentary

Responses to this question should provide two distinctive and contrasting ways in which Muslims celebrate Ashura

A good way to show contrasting approaches is to describe the differences between Shi’a and Sunni Muslims and how they view Ashura

However, it is also fine to explain contrasting celebrations within individual branches of Islam but be careful to ensure that the ways are distinctive and different from each other

Exam Tip

Id ul-Fitr and Id ul-Adha are different than Ashura and it is important to recognise why that is

Firstly, these two festivals are important for all Muslims, where as Ashura is more significant for Shi’a Muslims

Secondly, Id ul-Fitr and Id ul-Adha and celebratory festivals but Ashura is not a celebration as such. It is more of a somber commemoration particularly for Shi’a Muslims. Therefore, try to avoid words like celebrate within your responses

You've read 0 of your 0 free revision notes

Get unlimited access

to absolutely everything:

  • Downloadable PDFs
  • Unlimited Revision Notes
  • Topic Questions
  • Past Papers
  • Model Answers
  • Videos (Maths and Science)

Join the 100,000+ Students that ❤️ Save My Exams

the (exam) results speak for themselves:

Did this page help you?

Glenn Millington

Author: Glenn Millington

After graduating with a degree in Theology and Religious Studies, Glenn completed a PGCE over 20 years ago. He later gained an MA in Education Studies from the Manchester Metropolitan University. More recently Glenn completed a PhD in Educational Research focusing on educational disadvantage at Edge Hill University. Glenn is incredibly passionate about developing resources to enable students to succeed in Religious Education.