For the New Terminal Port |
Against the New Terminal Port |
Currently more than 5000 people in the Cayman Islands rely on cruise ship tourism for employment, and this will increase if the proposed development goes ahead |
Cruise passengers often stay on the cruise ship, and only visit for one day, so the amount of money they spend in the local economy is 55% less than long-stay visitors |
Building a new cruise terminal in the Cayman Islands will enable larger ships to visit the islands and allow visitors to disembark directly to shore, rather than those ships visiting other, more accessible, docking facilities instead |
There are concerns that damage to the environment by the proposed development, will discourage many long-stay visitors, who come specifically to experience the unique environments. |
Any reduction in cruise ship passengers, will mean fewer people will take tours, visit attractions and spend money in the local area, reducing the number of job opportunities for local people and leading to a negative multiplier effect (downward spiral) |
Damage to the coral reef and loss of wildlife - 15 acres of prized coral reef and home to the critically endangered Hawksbill Turtle, would be destroyed to make way for the development of not one but two cruise ship docks. |
The proposed development will create hundreds of new skilled and unskilled jobs and will help to regenerate George Town, which is one of the poorest parts of the island, so will help to increase quality of life and encourage future investment |
Loss of income for water sports and diving businesses. Day visitors don't have time to participate in these activities and increased visitor numbers can put off other tourists from staying any length of time - areas become crowded |
Cruise ship and cargo trade separated - visitors would no longer have to pass through containers and a working dock, increasing safety for passengers. 7.7 acres of land will be reclaimed from dredged material |
Extension of cruise port facilities in other parts of the Caribbean hasn’t generated extra income, but they have caused environmental problems - proposed project will dredge to a depth of 10m through the coral reef |
More cruise ship passengers coming ashore - no current docking facilities and passengers have to come ashore via small tenders over the island's prized coral reef. Waiting times are reduced, and visitors can spend more time ashore
|
Fewer people using small boat services, reducing job opportunities for local residents. Furthermore, 22 acres of seabed will have to be dredged to allow the cruise ships through. This will produce silt sediment which will pollute the water and harm the remaining coral reef by blocking sunlight to the photosynthesising algae that live on the coral polyps |
George Town Revitalisation will create living, business, leisure and entertainment space. The proposed pedestrianised area will bring improved safety for cyclists and tourists from better lighting; shading from new green spaces and seating for people to enjoy the cultural experience of the area |
There could be an increase in theft as George Town has some of the poorest parts of the island, creating opportunities for petty criminals. Increased pollution - water, light, noise, plastic, soil and increased waste. This will damage the pristine image of the island as well as damage the environment that present and future generations rely on for a living |